How e-bike frame sizes work
One bike says medium and another carries a plain number, yet they look the same size. That's not a mistake. The two labels may be counting different things.
What the label usually stands for
Traditionally, a frame's size was the length of its seat tube. That's the tube that runs up from the pedals to the saddle. The usual measure ran from the centre of the bottom bracket, where the cranks attach, to the centre of the top tube.1
Sheldon Brown, a long-time bike writer, puts it the same way: when you see a single number, it generally refers to the seat tube length.2
So a "17" is most likely a seat tube length in inches. A "54" is most likely the same idea in centimetres. Many brands also list Small, Medium or Large, and some still use inches for frame measurements.3
Why the same number can mean different things
Here's the first trap. Nobody agrees where the seat tube ends. Sheldon Brown describes the old standard as measuring to the very top of the seat tube.2
Other makers measure to where the top tube's centreline meets the seat tube's centreline. Some measure slanting top tubes as if they were level.2
His verdict is blunt. Seat tube sizes are nearly meaningless unless you know how they are measured.2
Why the system changed
Seat tube length used to describe a frame well. Today it often doesn't. Wikipedia notes that a wider range of frame shapes has led to other ways of measuring frame size.1
A guide from Bicycle Guider adds that sizes were once based on frame parts like the seat tube, but makers have since updated their systems to match modern geometry. Because some still use older methods, you'll see mixed standards.3
Geometry is just the lengths and angles of the frame. A separate page, what the rows of a geometry chart mean, goes through them.
Fixing the confusion in order
- Find the maker's own size chart for your exact model. Road bikes and mountain bikes often use different numbers for the same rider height, so a chart for another bike type won't help.3
- Check whether the chart says what its size number measures. If it doesn't, treat the number as a label only.
- Match your own measurements to the chart. How to take them is on its own page.
- Compare the actual lengths, not just the label, when you're weighing two bikes. Reach and stack are the two lengths to start with.
Slanting top tubes
Slanting top tubes make this harder. Some makers size a bike with a slanting top tube as if the tube were level.2
When a chart and a bike disagree, trust the maker's manual or support page for that model. The reasons for the gaps between brands are set out in a page on how makers differ.
Notes and sources
- Bicycle frame, Wikipedia
- Revisionist Theory of Bicycle Sizing, Sheldon Brown
- Bike Size Guide to Choosing the Right Fit, Bicycle Guider