Skip to content

Why size charts differ between makers

Reviewed on 17 November 2026

You wear a medium in one maker's bike and the next maker's medium feels wrong. Nothing's faulty. The letter on the frame doesn't mean the same thing everywhere.

There's no universal system

Bicycle Guider says plainly that there isn't a universal system that works for every bike and every rider.1

Its explanation is that makers take different approaches to frame design, geometry, and tube measurements and angles. Brands also aim at different audiences and intended uses.1

Frame shape follows use too. Wikipedia says the geometry of a frame depends on its intended use, and gives the example that touring frames tend to be longer while racing frames are more compact.2

Some causes

  1. Different ways of measuring. Sheldon Brown describes makers that now measure to where the top tube and seat tube centrelines meet, rather than to the top of the seat tube.3 The same number then covers different frames.
  2. Different rules for each size step. On modern bikes the smaller sizes have shorter top tubes and the larger sizes have longer ones.3
  3. Different bike types. The same rider height can map to different numbers on a road chart and a mountain chart.1
  4. Different labels. Letters, inches and centimetres all turn up. Bicycle Guider says these sizes don't always match across companies.1

Sheldon Brown's verdict on seat tube sizes is blunt: without knowing the method, the number says little.3

Comparing two makers' chartsWrite down both size labelsList reach and stack for eachNote how each maker measures sizePick the size nearest your fit
Compare the numbers, not the letters.

What to do about it

Don't carry a size from one brand to the next. Do these instead.

  • Use the chart for the exact model you're looking at. A general chart is only a start.1
  • Compare reach and stack, the extra numbers geometry charts list because sizes don't always match across companies.1 There's a short explainer on reach and stack.
  • Check standover on its own row. This note covers why it can vary.
  • Read how the maker defines its size number. If the manual or support page doesn't say, ask.
  • Take your own numbers first, as described in the measuring notes.

When two charts still disagree

You may find that a medium from one maker lines up with a small from another. Given the causes above, that's no surprise. It's a reason to trust measurements over letters.

Bicycle Guider advises using general charts as a starting point and then double-checking with the brand's own chart.1 The maker's support page, or a shop that stocks that model, can say more than a general chart can.

The rows you'll see in a chart are explained in our guide to geometry tables.

An example of the same label, two meanings

Sheldon Brown describes one bicycle line that made a running change in the middle of a year. Two bikes of the same make, model, year and nominal size could differ in actual size, and the only way to know was to measure them.3

That's an extreme case from one writer's account, not a rule. It shows why a label alone can't tell you the fit.

Notes and sources

  1. Bike Size Guide to Choosing the Right Fit, Bicycle Guider
  2. Bicycle frame, Wikipedia
  3. Revisionist Theory of Bicycle Sizing, Sheldon Brown