Seat tube length and saddle height
Your saddle is too low, yet the seatpost looks like it's out as far as it goes. Or the chart says one size and the saddle won't reach a comfortable height. Two different measurements are getting mixed up here.
Two numbers, two jobs
Seat tube length is a property of the frame. It's the tube running up from the bottom bracket, and it has traditionally been used as the frame size.1
Saddle height is set by you. It's the distance from the centre of the bottom bracket to a point on top of the middle of the saddle.2
The link between them is the seatpost. The saddle height is adjustable by changing how far the seatpost is inserted into the seat tube.2
Sheldon Brown notes that tall seatposts of 250 mm and 300 mm are now stock items.1 The post must still stay inserted at least to its minimum insertion mark, so follow your own bike's manual.
The minimum insertion mark
A seatpost usually has a mark showing its minimum insertion, or maximum extension.3 The post must be inserted at least a certain length, and the mark shows where that is.2
BikeRadar describes it as the minimum amount of post that must sit in the frame to maintain the post's structural integrity.4
Where the mark should sit when you set your saddle is a safety question. Follow the manual for your own bike.
Troubleshooting a saddle that won't go where you want
Work down this list.
- The mark is showing and you want the saddle higher. Check your manual for the minimum insertion. Ask the maker or a shop whether a longer post suits your frame. The size of a seatpost depends on the inside dimensions of the seat tube.3
- You've cut the post. BikeRadar says that if you cut a seatpost to reduce its length, this needs to be accounted for in regard to its minimum insertion.4 Follow the maker's manual, or ask the maker.
- The post is a different size. The post has to suit the seat tube's inside dimensions, so look up the right diameter in your manual rather than guessing.3
- There's no mark at all. Look in the manual for the minimum depth for your model, or ask the maker.
Where this fits in sizing
Seat tube length shows up in the old way of naming frame sizes, covered in the page on frame size labels. For the numbers that describe the front of the bike, see the reach and stack notes.
What the seat tube doesn't decide
Sheldon Brown argues that seat tube height is no longer the most important frame dimension. More determinant of how the rider sits, he says, is the top tube length.1
Wikipedia notes that frame geometry covers the angle of the seat tube as well as its length. Designers often compare the seat tube angle and the seat tube length.2 So two frames with matching seat tube lengths can still place the saddle differently.
That's why seat tube length, taken alone, tells you little. Check the maker's chart for the model, and follow the manual for any seatpost adjustment.
Notes and sources
- Revisionist Theory of Bicycle Sizing, Sheldon Brown
- Bicycle frame, Wikipedia
- Seatpost, Wikipedia
- Everything you need to know about seatposts: materials, diameters, lengths and more explained, BikeRadar